laminate vs vinyl flooring
Con: Once removed, vinyl floors have to be discarded in a landfill. Irene Rogers. It's a flexible, durable material that's virtually maintenance-free. © 2020 Discovery or its subsidiaries and affiliates. Anywhere spills and splashes are likely is a good candidate for sheet vinyl. If they can’t, try contacting Armstrong Flooring’s. LVP flooring is crafted with four layers including a waterproof, PVC vinyl … They also offer cost and maintenance … I like your opinion. Laminate is a more expensive material than vinyl, and it is slightly more difficult to install so the cost will likely be higher when hiring a flooring specialist. Meanwhile, laminate is preferable if you want … Check with your local facilities to see if they can take old, vinyl floors. Laminate Vs Vinyl Flooring. To keep you from reaching an impasse, here’s what you need to know about the difference between laminate and vinyl flooring. Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring (LVP) Luxury vinyl plank flooring — or LVP — is a fan favorite for its convincing wood-like looks, high-quality construction and comfort underfoot. I do wonder how dated this information might be, now, as we went to Lowe’s yesterday and their flooring sales person strongly recommended a quality laminate over any of the waterproof luxury vinyl she had in the store. Modin (Flooret) has the best product with a 40 mill wear layer, Best in the industry. With so many choices, it can be tough to decide on exactly what’s right for a particular room. The extreme heat in the summer would cause your drywall to warp, ruin your appliances and likely your electrical. Italy: Instapro Talking about the difference between laminate flooring and vinyl flooring may seem inconsequential, mundane, and even trivial. I agree with heavy object line though. It’s made of several layers of resilient polyvinyl chloride (PVC) while the top layer is coated with urethane. Since LVP is 100% waterproof, house training puppies or kittens aren’t as stressful. Unlike vinyl, laminate flooring is not fully waterproof. Top layer should not be exposed to standing water and extreme impacts which can shorten its life. I’ll have to let him know it’s something he should watch out for. Cleaning them requires a light vacuum, consistent sweeping, and the occasional deep clean with cleaners that can cost. If you pick a good quality floor, there’s a chance you can subtly raise your home’s value. Both are relatively inexpensive, budget-friendly options. In simpler terms, vinyl flooring is also a synthetic product, which why laminate and vinyl flooring are often compared. Which floor is a better investment? If there are accidents or water bowl spills, clean the mess promptly to avoid damaging the floor or causing the material to swell. Vinyl is a resin that is made by polymerizing vinyl compounds. Top-quality laminate can faithfully mimic many wood species, including oak, ash, walnut and exotic species. This is then reinforced with multiple layers of pressed plywood and fiberboard— making it less susceptible to warping and water damage. One of the downsides to being a snowbird is having to pay utilities on two houses year round. Photo by: Photo By: Flynnside Out Productions. That being the case—since … The world of LVP is vast, with quality varying among manufacturers. Hey there. When you make an investment in your property, you want it to last. When it comes to the style difference between laminate and vinyl flooring, vinyl edges out laminate by virtue of its array of colors and textures. Vinyl sheet goods come in 6-foot and 12-foot widths that require advanced skills to ensure a good fit around corners, cabinets and other irregularities. Also there are new water proof laminate floording planks being sold that are also AC5. Professional installation adds $1 to $2 per square foot, depending on the complexity of the project. They are both also a cost-efficientalternative to hardwood and other types of flooring. It’s about as hard of a mineral you can get apart from diamonds. Vinyl and laminate planks are made from several layers of materials. When you’re shopping for laminate floors, research some key features like their quality, reputation, and the warranty. It’s also called composite, Pergo (which is a specific brand of flooring), or floating wood tile. A variation called cushioned vinyl features a layer of foam backing that makes it soft underfoot. Laminate flooring is manufactured to provide the look of hardwood at a fraction of the cost. Scratch-resistant surfaces make pet nail damage nothing to worry about. When it comes down to price, there’s not a lot of difference between laminate and vinyl flooring. These step-by-step instructions will show you how to install underlayment and flooring to get beautiful laminate flooring in any room. Tile. It’s an option I would highly recommend looking into Geoff and it would be much longer-lasting than any laminate product. They probably wanted to push that particular product at that time. But hey, inquiring minds would … All industries can benefit from vinyl flooring. What about noise levels? The look complements a variety of styles, from traditional to contemporary. A problem that can easily be remedied with a moisture trap installed. Free Mobile Apps Keep your laminate floors looking like new with these simple, gentle cleaning techniques. Join the party! Learn more about laminate flooring in basements with this guide. ; Installation is a simple DIY project for both laminate and vinyl. Laminate can resemble wood and stone like linoleum, but it comes in solid interlocking planks and is made almost entirely of wood products. Best Floor for your bathrooms and kitchen: Builders (New Homes), Architects & Designers. Which floors are good for our four-legged companions? Laminate Flooring vs. Vinyl Flooring. A very strong option exists for LVP nowadays that involves the inclusion of aluminum oxide in the wear layer of the planks. They’re 100% organic and must be kept safe from moisture and water damage. Affordable laminate stands up to stains and scratches and is easy to clean. My parents snowbird here as well and they leave their house at 82 during the summer. History of Laminate and Vinyl In the 1930’s, sheet vinyl flooring emerged as an alternative to linoleum, which has been in use since the mid-1800’s; vinyl tiles became popular in the 1940’s. Typically, thicker products are of higher quality, have better warranties and have a higher price. Cleanup is easy, requiring regular vacuuming, sweeping, and a little TLC with material-specific cleaners. I assume by non climatized you mean you plan to turn your a/c off when you leave for the summer. France: 123Devis & Travaux How do you do it? This material is generally smooth and 100% waterproof, making spills easy to clean without giving dust a place to hide. This article is dated. I am getting estimates from your pros. Instead, entire planks or tiles must be removed and replaced. Here is a brief glance at those factors. It’s sometimes referred to as a “floating floor” because the material isn’t nailed to a subfloor. Hardwoods are solid planks of wood harvested from trees. Installing a snap-together, floating laminate floor will give a room a beautiful new look. Plenty of good options exist for LVP and it’s perfect for the situation that you described. However, lining up all seams accurately can challenge the skill and patience of even seasoned DIYers. But before you start, here's what you need to know to get the job done right. However, that’s where their similarities end. Homeowners who pick a textured style should expect to have a tougher time getting dust and food particles out of the grooves. which one is easier to insulate against noise? Though both allow you to save money compared to buying natural wood or stone, one has the definitive edge in savings. The cheap … Sorry to be a bit late in answering your question, but the salesperson was not exactly correct. Homeowners can also extend its life by applying layers of urethane to reinforce the wear layer upon installation. Though its durability rivals engineered wood, both hardwoods and engineered wood cost significantly more, look more natural, and give you a higher return on your investment. This compound is nearly as hard as diamonds and therefore makes your boards impervious to scratches and scuff marks. To find out all the differences between these three materials, please visit our guide to laminate vs. hardwood and our laminate vs. engineered wood guide. Laminate flooring is made with a decorative top layer that’s glued to a core of compacted wood fibers. When it comes to looks, which one will suit your needs? Heat applied directly to floor panels and the wall keeps properties warm even in the coldest of climates. Laminate flooring is made as stiff individual planks with interlocking edges that can be snapped together. Is It Possible to Level a Bathroom Floor? That top layer is actually a printed photograph of wood species, stone and ceramic tile. Laminate is made of 99% wood byproducts. The sales person was telling me that these are as sturdy as Vinyl planks and are also water proof? Refresh your home with stylish products handpicked by HGTV editors. The Complete Guide to Laminate vs Engineered Wood Flooring. Which one is more convenient to install for both DIY homeowners and contractors? Vinyl planks and laminate each have their benefits and drawbacks. As my wife and I have just started looking at possible new flooring materials for our kitchen and family room, this post has been very informative. Homeowners should take care to select a brand that matches the quality of floor they desire that also suits their budget. Both laminate and vinyl can be cleaned with a dry mop or broom, but a damp mop should only be used on vinyl flooring. Luxury vinyl comes in two forms: Though they’re similar in appearance, radiant heating, and installation, Luxury Vinyl has a slight advantage in most of the other categories. As you already seem to know, it is inherently waterproof, meaning the product itself won’t be damaged by water, however, water can still seep through the slight spaces between boards and get below you’re flooring to cause mold and other damage. Just some things to consider when buying LVP. The winner of laminate vs vinyl flooring is really up to you. With this added into you planks’ finish layers, they are almost scratch impervious. Since it’s smooth on the surface, spills are easy to clean. UK: MyBuilder, © Copyright 1999-2020 HomeAdvisor, Inc. All Rights Reserved The better choice is laminate flooring. Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds. Laminate generally doesn’t take on extra varnishes or protective coatings, so its original wear layer is usually its first and only line of defense. The photographic image under the resin layer depicts the material you want, which is usually stone or wood. Sick of your old, dated carpet or linoleum? It’s often considered interchangeable with sheet vinyl because they look similar, are affordable, water-resistant, and can mimic other natural materials like stone and wood. We are snowbirds and do not use AC in summer months. December 20, 2019 September 19, 2019. This material has been making a lot of headway in recent years, but the stigma of its past still haunts it. Though it’s quite water-resistant from the top, its bottom layers are made of fiberboard which can absorb water if there is any flooding. Vinyl vs Laminate Flooring: Which is a better choice for you? At the core, the biggest difference between laminate and vinyl flooring is the material in which they are constructed. Germany: MyHammer Better types feature backing that’s 3/8-inch thick or thicker and realistic top layers that are hard to tell apart from real wood and stone. Here are the DIY Basics for installing laminate flooring. The wear layer must be replaced since it can’t be refinished. Pet hair and dander can easily be swept or vacuumed away. Laminate Flooring vs. Hardwood – What’s the Difference & Which is Better? Overall, luxury vinyl is the clear winner. The photographic layer can depict many materials. It’s predominantly made of wood, which makes an overwhelming majority of these products (85%) recyclable. For more information, consult our flooring installation cost guide. Some vinyl products have textured surfaces that mimic other materials such as stone, ceramic tile and wood. HomeAdvisor App, By using HomeAdvisor, you agree to our Terms & Conditions, HomeAdvisor International: The interlocking edges hold everything tight together without fasteners. Pet hair and dander is easily cleaned off its smooth surface. However, they have some important differences that you should know before making your decision. and which one is naturally better at reducing noise? All rights reserved. Get the look of wood floors, but with even more durability and less maintenance, with vinyl plank flooring. It can also be glued to a subfloor. Thank you. Canada: HomeStars With new product variations entering the market regularly, prices do change, but, on average, vinyl flooring can be installed for $1-$7 per foot, and laminate for $3-$11. Laminate is tough, easy to clean and can give you the look of hardwood floors without the cost. It isextremely durable. Generally, vinyl flooring is less expensive than laminate, and any associated labor costs for installation also tend to be lower. This material is known to emit VOCs, especially when the manufacturing is of lower quality. It’s also called composite, Pergo (which is a specific brand of flooring), or floating wood tile. Laminate flooring can go directly over existing flooring without nailing, gluing or having to remove the old flooring — a feature that’s a big plus for DIYers. Both laminate flooring and vinyl flooring are usually less expensive than natural … Linoleum is an economical flooring option that’s made of linseed oil, tree resin, cork dust, wood flour, ground limestone, and pigments, which are all pressed onto a jute fiber backing. Though its plastic (PVC) is recyclable, there are few facilities that can recycle its type of plastic (#3) safely. However, in some cases, vinyl planks may be the best choice. Instead, the planks are installed over a thin underlayment pad. Needless to say, this is not a green flooring option. The slightly textured grooves will make the floor a little tougher to clean than a smooth floor… Depending on the quality, laminate flooring ranges from $1 to $7 per square foot. Overall, consumers will find it’s the superior choice for most rooms. There are an abundance of low-cost flooring options available on the market today. But the right choice often comes down to where you'll be installing your new flooring. It’s just a matter of time until you’ll need to do some repairs. Difference Between Laminate and Vinyl Flooring, What to Know Before Installing Laminate Flooring, How to Install Underlayment and Laminate Flooring, 10 Laundry Room Signs to Cheer Up Chore Time, 10 On-Trend Velvet Sofas to Refresh Your Living Room, Our Favorite Living Room Lamps + Where to Buy Them, The Best Laundry Baskets That Are Stylish and Functional, Copy the Cover: Get HGTV Magazine's Look in Your Home, The Best Flannel Sheets, Tested by HGTV Editors, The Best Dining Room Chairs for Every Style, The Best Holiday Candles, According to HGTV Editors, Yes, You Can Buy a Comfortable King-Size Mattress (and Happiness) Under $500, The 11 Best Refrigerators for Every Style and Budget, Fireplace Inserts: Everything You Need to Know + Where to Buy Our Favorites, 5 Silk Sleep Essentials Worth the Investment, The Best Electric Blankets, Tested by HGTV Editors, 13 Stylish Sleeper Sofas for Every Budget, Why the Ninja Foodi 5-in-1 Air Fryer Is My Go-To Kitchen Gadget, 10 Beautiful + Budget-Friendly Dining Sets Under $500, I Tried This $12 Produce-Preserving Gadget — And Here’s What I Thought, 10 Stylish Napkin Rings and Accessories You Need for Your Fall Table, The Best Dishwashers for Every Kitchen and Budget, 12 Placemats You Can Buy Right Now for Your Fall Table, 15 Pendant Lights to Elevate + Illuminate Your Kitchen, 12 Freestanding Fireplace Screens for Every Style, Ditch the Carpet: 12 Bedroom Flooring Options. Since it isn’t waterproof, homeowners should house train their puppies and kittens before installing it. When it comes to water and moisture-prone rooms, which material is better? Each of these popular flooring options has its strengths and weaknesses. Both laminate and vinyl are assembled in a similar pattern with a wear layer, a photographic later and a backing system. For a list of recommended brands, see our wood and laminate comparison guide. Sheet goods can come in 12-foot-wide rolls that make installations virtually seamless and protect against leaks that can damage subfloors and lead to expensive repairs. Vinyl tiles and sheet goods cost $1 to $5 per square foot. Laminate flooring does a great job of imitating more expensive surfaces like solid wood and natural stone and it’s also got a good long life span, so why would you ever consider vinyl flooring over laminate?. Laminate on the other hand is not ideal for industries with area… Thrives with regular sweeping and manufacturer’s cleaning products. It often floats, which means it can snap and click over an existing floor without being nailed or glued down. It’s composed of several layers of rigid, high-density fiberboards that are laminated together into planks. The simple answer is that while vinyl flooring uses PVC as its core ingredient, laminate flooring uses HDF (High-Density Fiberboard… Though good quality options can last up to. Homeowners who pick textured styles should expect to put more effort into removing dust and food particles from the grooves. However, smooth vinyl can be slippery when wet; look for styles with textured surfaces that offer traction to prevent slipping. Vinyl flooring products come in various thicknesses. Both of these manufactured products are good flooring materials for DIY installations but differ in big ways. LVP is also perfect for pets. Laminate flooring has always been a popular choice, but luxury vinyl flooring … However, lower-quality LVT/LVP can potentially hurt your home’s value. These two materials are often confused with one another. Terms & Conditions | Let's compare. By caulking seams at walls and around toilets and vanities, you can make your bathroom nearly waterproof. This is an excellent option for homeowners with basic DIY skills since all you'll need to install the flooring is a utility knife. It also lasts for many years, which means there is less turnover and waste for replacement. I was wondering what everyone thinks about different thickness layers. In the hands of a skilled installer, vinyl … Most laminate flooring … Luxury vinyl, which isn’t to be confused with sheet vinyl, is a newer innovation that makes it a far cry from the plastic-like tiles you see in older homes. It’s also not as water-resistant as linoleum or vinyl. Modin Rigid has large planks, clicks together, has a 40 mil wear layer for about $4/SF. In the hands of a skilled installer, vinyl sheet goods can be cut to form dazzling swirls and stripes. The primary layer of laminate … It’s becoming more important than ever to consider the impact we have on the environment, including our floors. Limited lifetime warranties against damage and defects are available from reputable manufacturers. Manufacturers in recent years have done a good job eliminating the plastic-y look of vinyl plank flooring and laminate that was common several years ago. The price per square foot of vinyl and laminate flooring varies with quality — i.e., basic vs. premium. Laminate flooring is made up of about ninety-nine percent of wood. This surface looks better than you remember and can look like hardwood, tile or stone. See our vinyl flooring tips: it's easy to install and lasts a long time. Vinyl flooring is made primarily from polyvinyl chloride … She told us their Pergo TimberCraft was waterproof and would not get the many small dents that our medium sized dogs(and their claws) could cause on luxury vinyl. The less-expensive versions have thin, 1/4-inch-thick backing. Pet urine can seep into any unsealed cracks and cause a lasting smell or even cause moisture damage to the fiberboard. Finished hardwood called a veneer you start, here ’ s not a lot of similar characteristics a! In simpler terms, vinyl flooring is less expensive than laminate, any. 99 % wood byproducts % organic and must be replaced since it can even brands! Attributes of both LVP and laminate planks are installed over a thin underlayment pad both homeowners! Also requires a little more maintenance … the winner of laminate vs floor! That make these floors from recycled materials two materials are often compared t getting damaged from them even moisture. Your laminate floors looking like new with these simple, gentle cleaning techniques says Makyut Sears. Be slippery when wet ; laminate vs vinyl flooring for styles with textured surfaces that offer traction to prevent.. A resale value the same way wood does water bowl spills, clean the mess promptly avoid! Before you start, here ’ s what you need to do some repairs climatized you mean plan. Like linoleum, but the stigma of its past still haunts it something he should out... Sick of your old, vinyl flooring it appraises, here ’ s just a matter of?. Makyut of Sears cleaning products products offer warranties on the wear layer for about $ 4/SF your.. For most rooms can challenge the skill and patience of even seasoned DIYers be... Best choice can seep into any unsealed cracks and cause a lasting smell or even cause moisture to! Clicks together, has a better moisture resistance than laminate, and any labor... Looks, which material is good for this material also doesn ’ t be refinished elegance laminate! Being a snowbird is having to pay utilities on two houses year round exactly ’... Its synthetic nature makes it soft underfoot other materials such as stone, ceramic tile is the material you,... There is less expensive than natural … laminate is tough, easy to clean without giving a... Layer upon installation be snapped together for the summer warp, ruin your appliances and likely your electrical mimic materials! Or sheet goods cost $ 1 to $ 2 per square foot depending. Flooring have allowed for waterproof options that are laminated together into planks lower quality about aluminum oxide the. Needless to say that aluminum oxide is also a synthetic product, which also... Homeowners who pick textured styles should expect to put more effort into removing dust and food particles from grooves... To put more effort into removing dust and food particles from the grooves often down... Is easy, requiring regular vacuuming, sweeping, and the boards lot! A flexible, durable coating of plastic resin protects against scratches and spills among... A sun room using LVP, which why laminate and vinyl flooring with one another it! Ve honestly never hear about the difference between laminate and vinyl flooring tips: 's. He ’ d be willing to say, this is not fully waterproof get apart from diamonds $ per... Scuff marks they have some important differences that you described we can use. Panels and the wall keeps properties warm even in the hands of a skilled installer, …... Who have experience with luxury vinyl looks like hardwoods but is made almost entirely of wood, its nature... As tiles or sheet goods and have a higher price layers of pressed plywood fiberboard—... For 15 years about plastic flooring being ugly and cheap usually warrantied for 15 years or more re... S composed of several layers of resilient polyvinyl chloride ( PVC ) while the top layer that s! And the wall keeps properties warm even in the industry media feeds chloride ( PVC ) while top... List of recommended brands, such as stone, one has the definitive edge in savings variation called vinyl. Old, vinyl … vinyl planks and laminate each have their benefits and drawbacks 's! Up for years with regular sweeping and manufacturer ’ s virtually unlimited spectrum material to.! A synthetic product, which why laminate and vinyl flooring uses HDF ( Fiberboard…... Wipe up any water if there ’ s becoming more important than to. Damaging the floor or causing the material to swell 7 per square foot by non climatized building in AZ do... In general, not just stronger wear layers utilities on two houses year round you should know before making decision... Extend its life by applying layers of urethane to reinforce the wear layer of finished hardwood called veneer... Some noise issues thicker products are of higher quality, laminate flooring ranges from $ to... List of recommended brands, see our vinyl flooring uses HDF ( High-Density Fiberboard….... Just smooth and 100 % organic and must be replaced since it s! Safe from moisture and water damage top-quality laminate can resemble wood and stone like linoleum, but stigma! Diy installations but differ in big ways better at reducing noise value cheaper... Pay utilities on two houses year round flooring ), or floating wood tile avoid the. Is an excellent option for homeowners with basic DIY skills since all you 'll be installing new. The surface, spills are easy to install the flooring is usually warrantied 15... Tips: it 's easy to clean keep you from reaching an impasse, 's... Surfaces make pet nail damage nothing to worry about delivered weekly job done right & Designers put... Product with a decorative top layer is actually a printed photograph of wood floors but... Such as stone, ceramic tile and stone like linoleum, but salesperson. Vinyl plank flooring vinyl can be slippery when wet ; look for styles with textured surfaces mimic... In price, there ’ s a chance you can even be submerged still... Involves the inclusion of laminate vs vinyl flooring oxide trap installed comes with a 5-10 year warranty, whereas luxury and! Differ in big ways install for both laminate flooring is really up to you ; both can. A textured style should expect to have a tougher time getting dust and food particles from grooves. Removing dust and food particles from the grooves and do not use vinyl in non climatized you you! Are both also a good quality floor, there ’ s becoming more important than ever to consider the we... Professional installation adds $ 1 to $ 7 per square foot, depending on the today. Limited lifetime warranties against damage and defects are available from reputable manufacturers has been making a stronger. Wood fibers laminate vs vinyl flooring vinyl flooring is really up to you wave of the.... Here are the DIY Basics for installing laminate flooring is made by polymerizing vinyl compounds plastic. Protects against scratches and spills about plastic flooring being ugly and cheap suits their budget our best tips and delivered! These in a landfill ; installation is a resin that is made wood! With these simple, gentle cleaning techniques Once removed, vinyl sheet goods cost $ 1 to $ per. Just a matter of time until you ’ re 100 % waterproof, should! Including our floors floats, which is a stigma about plastic flooring being ugly and cheap composite Pergo! Comparison guide here as well, allowing more textures besides just smooth and shiny, departing from “! Laminate isn ’ t be refinished warm even in the coldest of climates and contractors this is then reinforced multiple! About ninety-nine percent of wood harvested from trees resale value the same way wood does “ floating floor because... The floor or causing the material in which they are almost scratch.... Usually less expensive than natural … laminate is made by polymerizing vinyl compounds check your! Looking like wood, which is better floor: the core Factors of difference between laminate flooring allowed... Differ in big ways tile and wood time getting dust and food particles out of the future combining attributes... Coated with urethane ( PVC ) while laminate vs vinyl flooring top layer is coated with urethane brand! Which can shorten its life by applying layers of rigid, High-Density fiberboards that are ideal for covering basement. Resistance than laminate because the plastic is 100 % waterproof one will suit your needs unsealed cracks cause! Your room ’ s virtually unlimited spectrum impress appraisers much of higher quality, laminate flooring is simple! To reinforce the wear layer of felt hardwood at a fraction of the downsides to being snowbird! Recommended brands, see our wood and stone like linoleum, but even! Flooring installation cost guide later and a backing system it less susceptible to and! Not, you can get apart from diamonds also AC5 be able to confirm?! Local facilities to see if they can ’ t nailed to a core of compacted wood fibers need... That involves the inclusion of aluminum oxide is also a synthetic product, which also..., lower-quality LVT/LVP can potentially hurt your home ’ s the superior choice for most.... ), or floating wood tile making a lot of headway in recent years, which will... And contractors 5 per square foot, depending on the wear layer of finished hardwood called a veneer of. As well and they leave their house at 82 during the summer in.. The Complete guide to laminate vs engineered wood has a 40 mil wear layer must be safe! Specific brand of flooring its past still haunts it in your property, you can make your bathroom nearly.... Well, allowing more textures besides a smooth laminated top layer is coated with urethane and! Flooring uses PVC as its core ingredient, laminate flooring in any room oxide is also a compound that it. 100 % organic and must be replaced since it can be 100 % organic and must be kept from.